Phelps, Mitchell? Phelps.
A week ago, it looked like would probably begin the season as the Yankees’ long man in the bullpen. Garcia was in competition for a rotation spot, but given his age and durability concerns he didn’t have a fighting chance. Last Friday, went out for his final Spring Training start and left after a couple of innings with a shoulder injury. Pineda was sent to the DL and Garcia made the rotation by default.
That set off a bit of a debate. Who should be the Yankees’ long man? The two main candidates were DJ Mitchell and David Phelps. By now, most of you know that Phelps got the job. While few fretted for too long as to which young pitching prospect would complete the Yankees’ bullpen some were surprised. Mitchell, 24, probably has the better raw stuff of the two. He had a fine Spring and seemed tailor fit for the job.
There were several consideration that undoubtedly went into this decision. Most importantly, the Yankees’ wanted the best man for long relief work over the next several weeks. This isn’t a long term position – either Pineda, or , or both will likely be returning in the next month or two – but in a tight division that has only gotten tighter, every run counts. Long term considerations must also be made. The Yankees would not want to, for example, stick Manny Banuelos in long relief and retard his development. Finally, it was and is always crucial to maintain a reserve of capable, stretched out pitching talent in the event of injury.
I wouldn’t want to call the second and third concerns obsolete, but thankfully for the Bombers depth in the high minor leagues makes the problem of starting pitching reserves only a minor consideration. And while Phelps and Mitchell are both talented pitchers, they are far down the organizational depth chart behind Pineda, Phil Hughes, Ivan Nova, Adam Warren, and Banuelos. The Yankees truly believe in Warren and that essentially ruled him out of bullpen work. But among the two candidates, the determining factor was short term capability.
With this in mind, I believe the right decision was made.
Let’s look first at Phelps. About half a year older than Mitchell, Phelps has been in the Yankees’ system since 2008 and in that time has pitched relatively well. Over the course of his career he’s 38-15 with a 2.61 ERA and a 3.66 K/BB rate. He’s come out of relief just once in that period, but looked strong in relief this Spring. In 17.1 Grapefruit League innings he had a 2.08 ERA and a 14/4 K/BB ratio. Phelps doesn’t have knockout stuff but his fastball velocity is more than acceptable, topping out in the mid-90s, and his command of three pitches in superb. If anything, Phelps is one of the more overlooked prospects in the Yankees organization. His future may be brighter than his Baseball America or Baseball Prospectus rankings would indicate.
What about Mitchell? Drafted four rounds ahead of Phelps in the 2010 draft, he debuted in 2009 and moved very quickly through the system. In three minor league seasons, he’s 38-20 with a 3.28 ERA. Another fantastic career line. Yet there is reason to believe Mitchell could struggle in an extended Major League role. His fastball sits in the low-90s, if that, and despite good movement and strong secondary stuff he’s never been much of a strikeout pitcher. His control is average. His greatest asset is a sinking fastball that allows him to pick up groundball outs and that certainly showed this Spring, with a 2.60 ERA in 17.1 innings though just a 13/9 K/BB ratio. But groundball pitchers are far more prevalent in the starting ranks. Relievers, especially long relievers, often enter games when the previous pitchers has gotten himself in a jam. The double play is the pitchers best friends, but groundballs fall for hits at a disproportionate rate and the ability to miss bats is strongly correlated with the ability to strand runners.
Advanced minor league talent is often tricky. There’s a balancing act in the analysis of these players between performance and pure scouting. In this case, I think the story is fairly consistent. Phelps is more ready for the Major Leagues and though Mitchell might, in the long run, become the better pitcher he would have been an inferior choice. David Phelps has often been overlooked but given his fastball velocity, command, control, and success throughout the minor leagues, he seems well suited for the role of long reliever.
2 Responses to Phelps, Mitchell? Phelps.
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
-
LIKE TYA ON FACEBOOK
-
Recent Activity
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
- on Yanks lose 4-1
- bornwithpinstripes on What’s different about 2012 Kuroda?
- Professor Longnose on May 17 Game Thread
- Phil C on May 17 Game Thread
- Professor Longnose on May 17 Game Thread
- Phil C on May 17 Game Thread
- Professor Longnose on What’s different about 2012 Kuroda?
- bg90027 on What’s different about 2012 Kuroda?
- Professor Longnose on What’s different about 2012 Kuroda?
- oldyankee7 on Is Arod’s Bat Speed Really Declining?
-
Authors
Twitter
* TYA Twitter -
* EJ Fagan -
* Matt Imbrogno -
* William J. -
* Larry Koestler-
* Moshe Mandel -
* Sean P. -
* Eric Schultz -
* Matt Warden -
-
Most poker sites open to US players also provide online casinos accepting USA players. A good example of this is BetOnline.com, where you can play 3D casino games, bet on sports or play poker from anywhere in the United States.
-
Other Links
-
Blogroll
Blogs
- An A-Blog for A-Rod
- Beat of the Bronx
- Bronx Banter
- Bronx Baseball Daily
- Bronx Brains
- Don't Bring in the Lefty
- Fack Youk
- It's About The Money
- iYankees
- Lady Loves Pinstripes
- Lenny's Yankees
- New Stadium Insider
- No Maas
- Pinstripe Alley
- Pinstripe Mystique
- Pinstriped Bible
- River Ave. Blues
- RLYW
- Steven Goldman
- The Captain's Blog
- The Girl Who Loved Andy Pettitte
- The Greedy Pinstripes
- This Purist Bleeds Pinstripes
- Value Over Replacement Grit
- WasWatching
- Yankee Source
- Yankeeist
- Yankees Blog | ESPN New York
- Yankees Fans Unite
- YFSF
- You Can't Predict Baseball
- Zell's Pinstripe Blog
Writers
- Bats (NYT)
- Blogging the Bombers (Feinsand)
- Bombers Beat
- Buster Olney
- E-Boland
- Jack Curry
- Joe Posnanski
- Joel Sherman
- Jon Heyman
- Keith Law
- Ken Davidoff
- Ken Rosenthal
- LoHud Yankees Blog
- Marc Carig
- Tim Marchman
- Tom Verducci
Resources
- Baseball Analysts
- Baseball Musings
- Baseball Prospectus
- Baseball Think Factory
- Baseball-Intellect
- Baseball-Reference
- BBTF Baseball Primer
- Beyond the Box Score
- Brooks Baseball
- Cot's Baseball Contracts
- ESPN's MLB Stats & Info Blog
- ESPN's SweetSpot Blog
- FanGraphs
- Joe Lefkowitz's PitchFX Tool
- Minor League Ball
- MLB Trade Rumors
- NYMag.com's Sports Section
- TexasLeaguers.com
- THE BOOK
- The Hardball Times
- The Official Site of The New York Yankees
- The Wall Street Journal's Daily Fix Sports Blog
- YESNetwork.com
-
Site Organization
Categories
Tags
A.J. Burnett ALCS Alex Rodriguez Andy Pettitte Baltimore Orioles Bartolo Colon Boston Red Sox Brett Gardner Brian Cashman Bullpen CC Sabathia Chien-Ming Wang Cliff Lee Curtis Granderson David Robertson Dellin Betances Derek Jeter Francisco Cervelli Freddy Garcia Game Recap Ivan Nova Javier Vazquez Jesus Montero Joba Chamberlain Joe Girardi Johnny Damon Jorge Posada Manny Banuelos Mariano Rivera Mark Teixeira Melky Cabrera Michael Pineda Minnesota Twins New York New York Yankees Nick Johnson Nick Swisher Phil Hughes Prospects Red Sox Robinson Cano Russell Martin Statistical analysis Tampa Bay Rays Yankees -
Site Stats
One thing about Mitchell. Sinkerballers tend to need regular work to stay sharp, or else they’re worthless. Given the role (long man) available, Phelps’ more diverse repertoire figures to translate better.
Another good point. You just don’t see many sinkerballers in the bullpen.